How to see creativity and spirituality as a matched set
I have found that two experiences in life are a matched set. Creativity and spirituality.
Where you find spirituality you will find creativity. And vice versa.
The more open I open to growing deeper, and to receiving wisdom, the less my analytical mind can operate, and the more the other side of my brain, the side that moves intuitively, that sees wonder in the dawn, that feels inspired to add spice to the soup, and sees possibility in desperate circumstances begins to operate. My spirituality spawns creativity. Or would that be creativity spawns spirituality?
Creative but not spiritual?
I wonder, is there such a thing as someone who is creative but not spiritual? Musically talented but not given to daily prayer, a gourmet chef but not interested in matters of the spirit like the meaning of life? Gifted when sitting before a canvas, but not thinking about the source of Love or what happens after death?
I have spent swaths of my life pondering profound questions of life but I cannot sew, paint or sculpt. Does that make me spiritual but not creative? I know people who sew, paint and sculpt who never talk about Divine intervention in their endeavors. Does that exclude them from the ‘spiritual?’
What about creative spirituality? Does creative spirituality mean that we can make up, or create, our own spiritual path? Or that there is a message from God in our art and music?
I don’t believe this is an either/or question. To think of it this way is an example of dualistic thinking. (To read more, check out Yearning and Lust as Dualistic Thinking)
If you had to choose either ‘creative’ or ‘spiritual’ to describe yourself, which word fits you most closely? Don’t overthink this. One approach would be to ask which summer camp you would choose if you had to spend a week at one or the other – a music or art camp or a silent retreat at a zen monastery?
Your answer to this question does not preclude my premise that humans are both creative as well as spiritual beings, but it does illustrate our diversity in appetite as well as expression. And for most of us, comfort and familiarity with dualistic thinking and communication.
What is the difference between creativity and spirituality?
Creativity is focused on ‘doing’ or producing something that is beautiful or provocative to the eye, ear, or palette.
An artist sees, touches, and feels things differently than someone who has never developed their creative potential.
Creativity is also a mindset, a way of observing life from different perspectives and allowing for diversity in expression.
Thus you may enjoy French cuisine and wear retro fashion to a rock concert and your neighbor wears a tux to the symphony before going out for hot dogs. There is no one box for creative expression.
On the other hand, spirituality is about ‘being.’ If you self-identify more as a monk instead of an artist you may be drawn to meditation, prayer, and reflection and be comfortable with silence and solitude.
I love to go on retreat by the ocean and listen to the waves crash against the rocks. I get up before sunrise just to be in the mystery of the coming of the Light. I live in a world of questions, and the older I get, the more the questions have no answers.
And I am learning to be comfortable just ‘living the questions.’
The problem of dualism
My circle of relationships included people with day jobs like farming, construction, and daycare and who seemed to live a double life practicing the flute or writing haiku on the weekends. They didn’t see themselves as artists any more than I thought of myself as a writer. I did not make my living publishing books (a “doing”). The trouble is,
I wasn’t living like a monk either, sitting in meditation most of the day and rising in the night for prayer.
Do you see how dualistic thinking quickly leads to judgment and blame?
Although I am contemplative by nature I have an inner artist in the same way that I have an inner child and an inner mountain climber. I can talk about these ‘parts’ as if they were separate and distinct and yet I am one. I am whole.
Some questions for further thought
I am whole. And I am part. — Part of a greater whole of all creation. I have inherited thoughts and feelings, innate wiring that impacts my perceptions, and desires. Not only that, I have been shaped and formed by the trees I sit under, the carrots I eat, and the sun overhead. I am all. I am nothing. Tich Naht Hahn calls it “interbeing.” And that comes as close as any word to my understanding of creation.
So what are you to make of my reflective ramblings? I don’t know. Perhaps if I offer you some questions you will explore your own life and discover something about yourself you hadn’t thought about before.
How do you express your creativity?
How do you live into your spirituality?
Do you experience these as separate or conjoined?
How do they reflect a full and meaningful life for you?
You may find it helpful to journal these questions. And I would love to hear your responses.
[Photo credits from Unsplash: messy-creativity-Alice-Dietrich; kneading-bread-Julian-Hochgesang; dualism-face-and-hands-Elijah-Hiett; crystal-ball-Yeshi-Kangrang; cup-of-tea-yaopey-yong]
IF THIS ARTICLE ISN’T YOUR CUP OF TEA, YOU MAY PREFER DEKKER’S WRITING
(Click on the tab “Dekker” at the top of your screen)
Donna Marsh
I think of humans as a multifaceted gemstone…say a Ruby or such. The facets are different aspect of our being and only when turned into the light can it come forth to be illuminated. but since the light shows only one half than there is a darker side. This is not dualistic in that the stone itself is all one underneath. Creativity is an energy that brings us into existence and it fuels exploration into the field of possibilities. Its an expressive form that can yields immense beauty or not . Spirituality is a conscious awareness of what is in existence now and that it too chooses to explore with hopeful appreciation of life itself.
Creativity to me is being a toddler at play and when it grows up it becomes spirituality if nurtured.
Ardis Mayo
Donna, a wonderful reflection on Creativity compared with Spirituality!! Thank you for this.
Susan Shofner
WOW! I need to give creativity and spirituality more thought before I could decide on an answer. My quick response would be that my spirituality has caused me to take on the task of leading worship services when the pastor is off. And that has caused me to write sermons, select and sometimes write prayers and select music for a particular Sunday. So I guess one has lead me to the other.
Ardis Mayo
I see where you are coming from, Susan…but the leading of worship services, writing sermons, and selecting music is an enormous creative act!
Nan
Glad to see you’re up and running again!
Ardis Mayo
Thanks, Nan. When a website crashes it does call on more spirituality than creativity to endure the anxiety of getting it back up.
Margaret Lampasi
I like to think of myself as both! And not one or the other. I like the way you play off of the common thing we hear, “I’m spiritual but not religious”. Love the interbeing idea. Life and all of us are interwoven like a tapestry. Both / And conveys this. We all have so many aspects in us…. and yes, I agree that we are all whole, no matter what nurtured us or our natures. Personally, I love the idea of having being nurtured by nature–trees and the sun 🙂 Thanks for your interesting thoughts as always!
Ardis Mayo
You are welcome, Margaret. I love hearing the various perspectives of others, as I am sure many readers do.
Ardis Mayo
And thank you for your feedback, Margaret! The fun of reflecting is following the natural flow of the mind and where it takes us with ideas we may not have paused long enough to consider.
Ellen
I don’t feel much like a creative, I’ve never been very good at the creative things like music or art. I’m much more a spiritual person. I enjoy retreats and thoughtful times on my own. I love the comments of others on your article. I thoroughly enjoyed it.
Ardis Mayo
Thank. you for your feedback, Ellen. I am so glad you enjoyed the reflections. I too am more of a monk than an artist…but the older I get the more I see that creativity is all of the Spirit.
Peg Olson
Ardis,
You are definitely of both worlds, Creative and Spiritual!! Your gift of words, on paper and in conversation, is creative and your contemplative spirituality exhudes from your pores!
I wander from one “Camp” to another. Dabbling in each to find my way through life. I feel I don’t spend enough time in the contemplative “Camp” and yet music, art, cooking, and writing do push me to the spiritual “camp” while occuping my hands.
Peg
Ardis Mayo
Thank you for your kind words. I like the image you bring of ‘wandering’ in a sphere of wholeness.